Chumps. They’re all chumps.*
Either our expectations are too high, or all football managers are rubbish. To be precise, within English football there are only ever four good managers: dour genius Alex Ferguson, flawed genius Arsene Wenger, domestic-genius-on-a-shoestring (a role shared on rotation by David Moyes, Steve Coppell, Thingy Redknapp and Martin O’Neill) and foreign genius, the position currently filled by Juande Ramos.
All other managers are rubbish.**

A gratuitous photo of Roy Keane.
This is a phenomenon exclusive to English football, which explains why acclaimed managers from elsewhere such as Benitez, Houllier, Ranieri and Jol are jetted in, suddenly start managing like chumps and then leave, only to rediscover in somewhere like Zurich or Lyon or Turin that they’re quite good, actually.
The latest foreign manager to reveal his inner chump is Fabio Capello, the new England manager from Bracknell Southend San Canzian d’Isonzo. Now, the football writers don’t want to admit that he’s a chump. They have an enormous collective crush on him, like they did on Jose Mourinho. It reminds me of women in Regency novels simpering over the local doctor. Nevertheless, Capello has been displaying undeniably chumpish qualities, such as playing Wayne Rooney as a lone striker up front and suggesting (according to the hacks, anyway) that Beckham can be Rooney’s Ronaldo. (By which I mean he can supply Rooney with inch-perfect crosses, not with high-class call girls.) Capello has no chance - he may have been a wonderful manager once, but he’s in England now, and he can’t be good until Ramos displays a loss of form.
It strikes me that it would save an awful lot of money if clubs and the FA stopped employing managers altogether. It’s all about local empowerment. I have been reading about capacity-building and ‘development by people’, in which local communities are encouraged to participate in the decision-making process towards sustainable development footballing success. In other words, let the fans manage the team. They might not have been professional footballers, but I bet none of them would have played Jamie Carragher as a holding midfielder.
I propose the fans form a mini United Nations, in which representatives of each supporters faction meet in a General Assembly once a week to decide on tactics. The risk, of course, is that any decision would be delayed by a last-minute interjection from the Hong Kong Supporters Group and not be resolved until the match had finished, but that’s consensus politics. The national team would be managed by the country’s most recent lottery winner: “Today’s team was picked by Mr Dave Newt from Trowbridge.” Far better than giving Mr Newt £5.2 million just so he can pay off his mortgage and go on horrific cruising holidays for the rest of his life.
I realise this would narrow the career opportunities for professional footballers. But given that (a) all managers apart from Ferguson are eventually sacked anyway and (b) all managers like golf, I propose that every single football manager works at Leeds United Football Club. The position would rotate every week, which would give each manager a chance to shine before revealing himself as a chump, and afford him plenty of time off (approximately 13 years) to work on his handicap.
Of course, it is just possible that most managers only appear to be rubbish because expectations for their teams are simply too great. There can only be one winner, people! Maybe there should be joint first place in the Premiership for the top seven clubs, just so that Newcastle and Spurs and West Ham and Everton and all the other clubs who think that the national title has been overdue for 87 years can stop whingeing. Another solution might be to forbid a team from losing, so that if the score is 2-0 at the end of normal time, the goalkeeper hands the ball to the striker on the other team and invites him to pummell the ball into an empty net.
It always annoys me when there are calls for a national enquiry into The State of British Tennis or Why We Didn’t Win the World Cup or Our Shocking Olympics Medal Haul or whatever. We can’t be good at everything - our cup runneth over already with cycling and darts, surely? Perhaps I don’t entirely understand the competitive spirit, but why can’t we just say, “Golly, Serbia, you’re awfully good at tennis, aren’t you? Well done you!”
Or, “Hello, Ethiopia - bit of a dark horse at this long-distance running lark, aren’t you? Made us look like right plonkers!”
Or, “I say, Finland, isn’t is lucky that you can produce some of the world’s best rally drivers when you’ve got so much muddy forest all over the place!”
Each to their own, I say.
* Except Roy Keane.
** Ditto.